4 min read
There is a kind of sadness that is difficult to explain. It is the sadness of wanting to hold a baby you have never held. Of imagining a little face that you have never seen. Of wondering what it would feel like to hear someone call you “Amma” for the first time.
And sometimes, it is the sadness of watching someone else receive the very blessing you have spent years praying for.
You smile when your friend announces her pregnancy at a family wedding. You congratulate your sister. You hold someone else’s newborn during a naming ceremony. You genuinely feel happy for them. And then, when you are alone, your heart quietly asks: “Heavenly Father, what about me?”
That question does not make you faithless. It makes you human.
“Why Not Me?”
or some women, motherhood happens almost exactly as they imagined. They marry, become pregnant, hold their babies, and slowly discover the beautiful and exhausting world of raising children.
Some never marry. Some marry but cannot conceive. Some become pregnant but lose their babies. Some experience miscarriage after miscarriage. Some spend years going from one doctor to another, hoping the next appointment will finally bring good news. Some have medical conditions that make pregnancy impossible. Some desperately want children but never receive the opportunity to become mothers in mortality.
And sometimes, there is no satisfying explanation. That may be one of the hardest parts. Because when something hurts this deeply, we naturally want to know why. Why did she get pregnant so easily? Why did my body not cooperate? Why did God answer her prayer and not mine?* Why does someone who never seemed to want children receive them, while someone who has prayed for a child for years remains childless?
Why would a loving Heavenly Father allow a woman to carry such a deep desire and still leave that desire unanswered? I don't think we should be afraid of that question. And I don't think we need to give an easy answer. Because sometimes the most honest answer is: "We don't know".
God Has Not Told Us Every “Why”
The gospel teaches us that Heavenly Father has a plan for His children. We know that family is central to that plan. We know that motherhood and fatherhood are sacred responsibilities. We know that children are a gift from God. But knowing these things does not mean we understand every individual story.
The scriptures do not tell us why Hannah had to wait so long for a child. They do not tell us why Elizabeth experienced years of barrenness before becoming the mother of John the Baptist. They do not tell us why some righteous women in scripture experienced motherhood while others did not. And they do not tell us why one woman today conceives easily while another spends years praying for the same blessing.
The gospel does not promise that every righteous person will receive every desired blessing on the timetable they expect in mortality. And that is difficult. Faith does not mean pretending that it isn't. Faith sometimes means looking at something you cannot understand and saying: “I don't know why this is happening. But I still believe that God knows me.”
Infertility Is Not a Punishment
There is something every woman struggling with infertility needs to hear: Your infertility is not evidence that God is disappointed in you.
you did not fail a spiritual test because you could not become pregnant. You are not less worthy because your body did not do what you hoped it would do. You are not being punished for something you did in the past. You do not need to become “more righteous” so that God will finally give you a baby.
In our broader culture, there is sometimes a painful myth that not having children is a result of bad karma or a hidden sin. The Church has clearly taught that infertility is never a punishment for imperfections, weaknesses, or unworthiness.
Sometimes, well-meaning religious language can accidentally make this suffering feel heavier. We say things like: “Just have faith.” “Pray harder.” “God has a plan.” “Just relax, it will happen when the time is right.” Those words may be well intended. But to a woman who has just lost another pregnancy, or who has spent years hoping for a child, they can sometimes feel like an answer to a question she never asked.
She may not need an explanation. She may just need someone to sit beside her and say: “I know this hurts. You don't have to be strong with me.”
Heavenly Father Can Hear the Prayer Behind the Prayer
Perhaps the most painful prayer is not, “Please give me a baby.” It is, “Heavenly Father, please let me understand why You haven't.”
And sometimes there is no immediate answer.
Hannah knew this kind of longing. She went to the temple with a soul so deeply troubled that the priest Eli initially misunderstood what he was seeing. But the Lord knew exactly what was happening inside her heart. Her story reminds us that God does not only hear polished, perfect prayers. He hears the prayers that come with tears. He hears the prayers we cannot finish. He hears the questions we are afraid to say aloud. He hears: “Why?” “Why me?” “How much longer?” “Did You forget me?” And sometimes, faith is simply continuing to speak to Him even when heaven feels silent.
But What About the Promise of Motherhood?
This is where Latter-day Saint doctrine gives us a beautiful hope—but we must handle that hope carefully.
The Church teaches that the blessings of eternal life include eternal family relationships. God's promise of eternal life includes eternal marriage, children, and other blessings of an eternal family, including for those who are currently unmarried or without children in this life.
President Gordon B. Hinckley also tenderly taught that some women are not given the responsibility of bearing children in mortality, but that women who desire and work toward that blessing are promised it for eternity.
That promise is precious. But it does not mean we should tell a grieving woman:
“Don't worry. You'll definitely have a baby in the next life.”
We do not know exactly how every eternal blessing will unfold. We don't know the details. We don't know the timing.
But we do know something about the character of God.
He is just.
He is merciful.
He is perfectly aware of the deepest desires of His children.
And because of Jesus Christ, mortality is not the final chapter.
What If I Never Get to Hold My Baby Here?
Maybe this is the question that hurts the most. What if she never hears her baby cry? What if she never buys tiny clothes? What if she never packs a school lunch? What if nobody ever calls her “Amma”? What if she leaves this life still carrying the desire she carried for decades?
I don't want to answer that with a cliché. I don't want to say, “Everything happens for a reason.” Because sometimes we simply don't know the reason. Instead, I want to remember the doctrine of eternal families. The gospel teaches us that mortality is not the whole story. Our Heavenly Father sees the beginning, the middle, and the end. We see one page; He sees the entire book. And perhaps one of the greatest acts of faith is trusting the Author when we cannot yet understand the chapter we are living.
Your Empty Arms Do Not Mean an Empty Life
There is another truth that matters. A woman who does not have children is not a woman without purpose. But we should also be careful here. We should not tell a woman who desperately wants a baby: “Don't worry. You can just teach the children in the ward.” “You can just love other people's children.” “Think about all the people you can serve.”Those things may become beautiful parts of her life. But they do not erase the very specific, heavy grief of wanting a child of your own.
We can acknowledge both truths at the same time:
- Her life is deeply meaningful right now.
- Her longing for a child is real and valid.
She does not have to choose between gratitude and grief. She can be grateful for the life she has and still cry over the life she imagined. She can love her friends' children and still wish she had one of her own. She can have a strong testimony and still ask God, “Why?” She can trust Heavenly Father and still feel disappointed. Faith does not require us to stop feeling.
Maybe God Is Not Asking You to Stop Hoping
If you are a woman waiting for motherhood, perhaps you don't need to give up your hope.
You don't need to convince yourself that you never wanted children.
You don't need to pretend that pregnancy announcements don't hurt.
You don't need to feel guilty when someone else's happiness reminds you of your own unanswered prayer.
You can hope.
You can pray.
You can seek medical help.
You can consider adoption when it is right for you.
You can seek priesthood blessings and spiritual guidance.
You can grieve your losses.
You can ask questions.
And you can keep walking with Christ.
Because Jesus Christ understands a kind of pain that cannot be explained away. He knows what it means to ask whether there is another way. He knows what it means to suffer without receiving the answer we want.
And because He descended below all things, there is no lonely waiting place where He cannot find you.
To the Woman Holding Someone Else's Baby
Maybe you are reading this while sitting beside a friend who just became a mother. Maybe you are happy for her. But maybe there is also a small ache inside you.
If there is, you don't have to be ashamed of it. Your sadness does not mean you are jealous. Your tears do not mean you are ungrateful. Her blessing does not mean God loves her more. Someone else's answered prayer is not evidence that God has rejected yours.
You are still His daughter. Still known. Still loved. Still seen. Still worthy. Still part of His plan.
To the People Who Love Her
In our close-knit Indian families, everyone often feels entitled to ask about pregnancy plans. Please be gentle.
- Don't ask a newly married woman when she is going to have children.
- Don't ask why she hasn't become pregnant.
- Don't assume you know whether she is trying.
- Don't tell her that she should “just relax.”
- Don't use another woman's pregnancy as a lesson about God's timing.
- Don't make her private pain a public conversation.
And please don't measure her faith by whether she can smile when someone announces a pregnancy. Instead, love her. Invite her. Include her. Listen when she wants to talk. Let her cry without trying to fix her.
And if you don't know what to say, perhaps simply say: “I don't know why this is happening to you. But I am here, and you don't have to carry it alone.”
Sometimes, that is more Christlike than any explanation.
Heavenly Father Has Not Forgotten You
There may be women reading this who have asked the same question for years: “Heavenly Father, why didn't You give me this gift?
I don't know the answer. And neither does anyone else—not completely. But I know this: Your unanswered prayer does not make you forgotten. Your empty nursery does not make you empty. Your miscarriage did not make you less of a woman. Your infertility did not make you less worthy. Your marital status does not determine your value. Your family size does not determine your eternal worth.
You are a daughter of God. Before you ever became someone's wife. Before you ever became someone's mother. Before anyone ever called you “Amma.” You were His. And you still are.
The prophet Isaiah recorded one of the most tender promises in scripture:
“Can a woman forget her sucking child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb? … yet will I not forget thee.”_ [Isaiah 49:15
Notice what the Lord says. He doesn't say, “I will explain everything.” He says, “I will not forget thee.” Maybe sometimes that is the promise we need most. Not an explanation. Not a timeline. Not an easy answer. Just the assurance that in the middle of a story we do not understand, He has not forgotten us.
You Are Allowed to Hope
So if motherhood is still something you deeply desire, hope. If you need to grieve, grieve. If you need to ask God why, ask. If you need to step away from a conversation because it hurts, step away. If you need help, seek it. If you need to cry, cry.
And when you are ready, take another step toward Christ.
You don't have to understand God's entire plan to trust Him with your life. You only have to trust Him with today.
Maybe motherhood will become part of your mortal story.
Maybe it will come through a path you never imagined.
Maybe some of the promises you are waiting for will be fulfilled beyond this life.
We do not know every detail. But we know the Savior. And we know that because of Jesus Christ, no righteous desire, no covenant, no sacrifice, and no act of faithful love is ever wasted.
So, dear sister, if you are waiting for a child you have prayed for:
- Don't believe that God has forgotten you.
- Don't believe that your life has been put on pause.
- Don't believe that another woman's blessing makes your life smaller.
- And don't believe that you have to understand the “why” before you can have faith.
You can carry the question and still carry Christ.
You can carry the grief and still carry hope.
And perhaps, for now, that is enough.
He knows the child you never got to hold.
He knows the pregnancy you lost.
He knows the years you waited.
He knows every prayer you whispered.
He knows every tear you wiped before anyone saw it.
And even when you cannot see what comes next, He sees the whole story.
You are not forgotten.
You are not behind.
You are not less.
You are His daughter.
And your story is not over.
You may also be interested in